Madcap Coffee: Grand Rapids' Specialty Roaster Built for Curious Drinkers
Based in Grand Rapids, Michigan, Madcap Coffee has cultivated a devoted following across the Midwest with a philosophy that prizes transparency, accessibility, and genuine curiosity about where coffee comes from. Their current CoffeeByMe catalog is compact but carefully chosen: a pair of sessionable, easy-drinking blends designed for everyday moments, alongside a high-elevation single-origin Guatemala that showcases what thoughtful sourcing looks like at its most direct.
Both blends roast to medium (level 3) with moderate acidity and medium-to-full body, leaning toward caramel and chocolate-dark cherry character — reliable across brew methods and designed for everyday comfort without sacrificing quality. One sits a touch richer and rounder; the other is slightly drier and crisper, making it the more espresso-forward of the two. The single origin completes the compact catalog at a lighter roast: a washed Caturra from Guatemala at nearly 2,000 meters, with a distinctly fruit-forward profile — watermelon, rose, and raspberry — and livelier acidity that rewards slow pour-over brewing. CoffeeByMe's AI recommendation engine is especially well-suited to helping you decide between Madcap's crowd-pleasing blends and this expressive single origin, depending on whether you're brewing for a quick morning or a slow weekend pour-over.
Single Origins
| Name | Roast | Tasting Notes | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carlos Guamanga (WS) | Medium | Creamy Orange FruitPassion FruitSoft FloralsMangoElderflower | $895.00 |
| Carlos Guamanga | Medium | Creamy Orange FruitPassion FruitSoft FloralsMangoElderflower | $112.00 |
| Alirio Muñoz Ortega (WS) | Medium | Cotton CandyPineapplePink Lemonade | $925.00 |
Blends
| Name | Roast | Tasting Notes | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Afterhours | Dark | dark cherrymolasseschocolatesilky sweetness | $60.00 |
| Afterhours (WS) | Dark | dark cherrymolasseschocolatesilky sweetness | $60.00 |
| Placebo (Decaf - WS) | Medium | SweetDeepCreamy | $627.00 |
Roast Profile & Flavor Range
Madcap keeps its roast range tight and intentional. Both core blends sit at medium (level 3) with moderate acidity and body — designed to be reliably great without demanding specific brew methods. The single origin is the outlier, roasted lighter (level 2) with higher acidity to let the Guatemala terroir shine. At $14 for 4 ounces, it's a small-batch treat; the blends at $15.99 for 12 ounces offer some of the most accessible specialty coffee pricing in the Midwest market.
Why Buy Madcap Coffee
Accessible everyday blends: The two medium-roast offerings deliver familiar caramel and chocolate-dark cherry notes at a friendly price — ideal entry points for drinkers moving from commercial coffee to specialty.
High-elevation Guatemala single origin: A washed Caturra from nearly 2,000 meters showcases fruit-forward brightness — watermelon, rose, and raspberry — for pour-over enthusiasts who want to explore expressive terroir.
Price accessibility: All three offerings sit below $16 for standard sizes, making Madcap one of the most wallet-friendly Midwest roasters in the CoffeeByMe catalog.
Ideal for: Specialty beginners seeking a reliable everyday blend, weekend pour-over explorers, and anyone curious about how high-altitude Guatemalan growing conditions translate into the cup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Madcap Coffee located?
Madcap Coffee is a specialty coffee roaster based in Grand Rapids, MI.
What does Madcap Coffee specialize in?
Madcap keeps its roast range tight and intentional. Both core blends sit at medium (level 3) with moderate acidity and body — designed to be reliably great without demanding specific brew methods.
Where can I buy Madcap Coffee coffee?
You can browse Madcap Coffee's coffees on CoffeeByMe and click through to buy directly from the roaster, or visit Madcap Coffee's own website.
